Below is a diagnosis provided by The Plant Doctor regarding a pine tree disease in Amherst, Massachusetts.
-----------------------------------------------
Diagnosis requested from The Plant Doctor appSubmitted by user: March 2, 2010
Host plant name: Pine
Primary symptoms: Borer holes in wood; shallow rooting. Eventually tree toppled and was cut.
Plant setting: Landscape
Geographic location: Amherst Mass
Number of plants affected: 1
Additional information: I did not see the tree before it was cut.
Photographs:


----------------------------------------------
Response from the Plant DoctorDiagnosis: submitted to user on March 3, 2010
I received your request for diagnosis of the pine disease you observed in Massachusetts.
The lack of specific information you provided regarding the species name for this pine, the foliar disease symptoms, and the temporal progression of disease make it difficult to diagnose this problem with a high level of accuracy. However, given the information provided in text and photographs, I think there are two primary diagnoses which are likely for this problem: 1) root rot and/or 2) pinewood wilt disease.
DIAGNOSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
1) Root rot. I agree that the root system appears to be rather shallow and restricted. There also appears to be some root necrosis, or rot. That the tree toppled indicates a poorly developed root system or a rotten root system. The restricted growth of the root system could be due to a poor substrate (i.e., shallow soil, subtended by a layer of rock). The plant may have received too much water or irrigation, either by irrigation emitters or by being grown in a poorly drained substrate. There also could be a fungal root pathogen present, which may have caused the root rot and moved up into the stem to create the pattern of internal stem discoloration. One may still be able to recover a fungal root pathogen from either the roots or the vascular tissue within the stem. If the disease progressed slowly over many months or years, then root rot disease is a high probability for the primary cause of the problem. The cause of the root rot would probably be a combination of too much water in the root system plus the presence of a virulent fungal pathogen.
2) Pinewood wilt. Pine wilt is a disease of pine (Pinus spp.) caused by the pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus. The pinewood nematode is transmitted (vectored) to conifers by pine sawyer beetles (Monochamus spp.). Please see this article: http://www.na.fs.fed.us/spfo/pubs/howtos/ht_pinewilt/pinewilt.htm. "Usually the pines affected are Austrian (P. nigra), Scotch (P. sylvestris), and Japanese red and black pines. The disease occurs mainly in Midwest USA, but also occurs in Massachusetts.Pine sawyer beetles are attracted to weakened trees (hence, the disease could be associated with root rot, which adds stress to trees). In the United States, losses from pine wilt disease can occur in some non-native pine plantations and landscape trees. Management of pine wilt disease is primarily limited to prevention. There are no cures for pine wilt disease once a susceptible tree becomes infested with the pinewood nematode. The most effective prevention strategy is to avoid planting non-native pines, such as Scotch and Austrian pine, where the mean summer temperature is greater than 20°C. Where these non-native pines already exist, landowners can reduce susceptibility of high-value landscape trees by watering to avoid drought stress. If they discover infestations, landowners can consider removing and chipping infested trees to limit the spread to nearby susceptible trees." Given the presence of insect boring injury and internal stem discoloration (and if a relatively rapid wilt occurred for this plant), pinewood wilt is a relatively high probability for being a cause of the tree death (if wilt symptoms were present in the foliage).
In my opinion, for this tree there may be an interaction between root rot and pinewood wilt: a tree with root rot became stressed and attractive to the sawyer beetles, which vectored the pinewood nematodes, the cause of wilt (if wilt occurred) and toppling. The key for identifying the cause of the problem is how long it took for the tree to decline and topple and what type of foliar symptoms were present.
There are other factors which can cause the death of pine trees, such as pine pitch canker disease. However, as I mentioned, without knowing more I cannot identify the cause of the problem with any higher degree of accuracy. Nor can I provide any more specific disease management considerations, aside from sanitation (remove stump) and to avoid planting the same tree species in that location.
You are welcome to contact me with any questions about this diagnosis or to provide more information for my consideration. I also suggest that you contact the Cooperative Extension Service at the University of Massachusetts: http://www.umassextension.org/ for its opinion regarding this problem.
If you find this diagnosis helpful or satisfactory, please let us know by sending me a message or by posting a review of the app at the iTunes store.